Finding Collectibles

Hard to Find Collectibles, Vintage Knick Knacks, and More

Biggest group of peanut butter pail and many relevant items. Presenting Peanut Butter Pail available for sale here online.

Peanut Butter Pail On Sale

Buy Peanut Butter Pail on eBay now!

Circa 1920 Teddy Bear Peanut Butter Pail Tin C.and J. Jones Winnipeg Canada No Lid

Circa 1920 - $1,200.00

Circa 1920 Teddy Bear Peanut Butter Pail Tin C.and J. Jones Winnipeg Canada No Lid

1977 Shedd's Peanut Butter Pail Bucket Wacky Packages Ad Rare

1977 Shedd's - $599.99

1977 Shedd's Peanut Butter Pail Bucket Wacky Packages Ad Rare

Vintage Peanut Butter Advertising Tin Pail, Leader Brand, Martin Peanut Products

Vintage Peanut - $425.00

Vintage Peanut Butter Advertising Tin Pail, Leader Brand, Martin Peanut Products

Scarce Wilson's Certified Brand Peanut Butter Advertising Tin Pail Wlid

Scarce Wilson's - $398.00

Scarce Wilson's Certified Brand Peanut Butter Advertising Tin Pail Wlid

Rare Pickaninny Brand Peanut Butter Pail Antique Black Americana Advertising

Rare Pickaninny - $349.95

Rare Pickaninny Brand Peanut Butter Pail Antique Black Americana Advertising

Near Perfect Monadnock Peanut Butter Advertising Pail Great Color And Graphic

Near Perfect - $278.00

Near Perfect Monadnock Peanut Butter Advertising Pail Great Color And Graphic

Vintage Monadnock Brand Peanut Butter Pail Tin Can Advertising Keene Nh Holbrook

Vintage Monadnock - $224.99

Vintage Monadnock Brand Peanut Butter Pail Tin Can Advertising Keene Nh Holbrook

Graphic Old Toyland Peanut Butter Pail 2lb Size

Graphic Old - $195.00

Graphic Old Toyland Peanut Butter Pail 2lb Size

Vintage Eatagood Peanut Butter Pail Tin Can Advertising White River Junction, Vt

Vintage Eatagood - $189.99

Vintage Eatagood Peanut Butter Pail Tin Can Advertising White River Junction, Vt

Buffalo Brand Peanut Butter Tin Pail 1lb Bail Handle Amesbury, Ma Advertising

Buffalo Brand - $189.00

Buffalo Brand Peanut Butter Tin Pail 1lb Bail Handle Amesbury, Ma Advertising

Circa 1920 Old Tyme Canadian Maple Prod. Peanut Butter Pail Tin Toronto Canada

Circa 1920 - $180.00

Circa 1920 Old Tyme Canadian Maple Prod. Peanut Butter Pail Tin Toronto Canada

Rare Pickaninny Brand Peanut Butter Pail Antique Black Americana Advertising

Rare Pickaninny - $172.00

Rare Pickaninny Brand Peanut Butter Pail Antique Black Americana Advertising

Vintage Antique Rare Adv Teddy Teddie Bear Peanut Butter 5 Lb Primitive Tin Pail

Vintage Antique - $157.50

Vintage Antique Rare Adv Teddy Teddie Bear Peanut Butter 5 Lb Primitive Tin Pail

Vintage Peanut Butter Advertising Tin Pail, Fi-na-st, Finast, Fi-na-st, Jelly

Vintage Peanut - $135.00

Vintage Peanut Butter Advertising Tin Pail, Fi-na-st, Finast, Fi-na-st, Jelly

Fi-na-st Peanut Butter Vintage Tin Pail, First National Stores, Somerville, Mass

Fi-na-st Peanut - $129.00

Fi-na-st Peanut Butter Vintage Tin Pail, First National Stores, Somerville, Mass

Big Sister Peanut Butter Brand Pail 1900's Rusty

Big Sister - $129.99

Big Sister Peanut Butter Brand Pail 1900's Rusty

Sultana Peanut Butter Pail

Sultana Peanut - $125.00

Sultana Peanut Butter Pail

1926 Monarch 1 Lb. Teenie Weenie Peanut Butter Tin Pail

1926 Monarch - $125.00

1926 Monarch 1 Lb. Teenie Weenie Peanut Butter Tin Pail

Rare Vintage Cpc Peanut Butter Tin Pail California Peanut Co. Large 60lbs Pail

Rare Vintage - $97.19

Rare Vintage Cpc Peanut Butter Tin Pail California Peanut Co. Large 60lbs Pail

1926 Monarch Teenie Weenie 1 Lb Peanut Butter Advertising Tin Pail

1926 Monarch - $100.00

1926 Monarch Teenie Weenie 1 Lb Peanut Butter Advertising Tin Pail

Vintage Peanut Butter Advertising Tin Pail, Bel-car-mo, Belcarmo, Grand Rapids

Vintage Peanut - $95.00

Vintage Peanut Butter Advertising Tin Pail, Bel-car-mo, Belcarmo, Grand Rapids

Peanut Butter Tin Pail, Frontenac W-original Paper Seal-uncut, And Bail Handle

Peanut Butter - $95.00

Peanut Butter Tin Pail, Frontenac W-original Paper Seal-uncut, And Bail Handle

Vintage 6 14 High Shedd's Peanut Butter Tin Metal Circus Animals Pail Empty

Vintage 6 - $79.99

Vintage 6 14 High Shedd's Peanut Butter Tin Metal Circus Animals Pail Empty

Vintage Armours Veribest Peanut Butter Tin Pail, 1 Lb Advertising, Great Litho

Vintage Armours - $85.00

Vintage Armours Veribest Peanut Butter Tin Pail, 1 Lb Advertising, Great Litho

Antique Mosemann's Peanut Butter Tin Lancaster, Pa Pail 1 Lb Vintage Pail 1900's

Antique Mosemann's - $79.00

Antique Mosemann's Peanut Butter Tin Lancaster, Pa Pail 1 Lb Vintage Pail 1900's

1950s The Peanut Kids Peanut Butter Bucket, 5 Pounds Pail, Suffolk, Va

1950s The - $74.99

1950s The Peanut Kids Peanut Butter Bucket, 5 Pounds Pail, Suffolk, Va

Antique Advo Advertising Peanut Butter Tin pail Empty

Antique Advo - $70.00

Antique Advo Advertising Peanut Butter Tin pail Empty

Tiny Red Seal Peanut Butter Advertising Tin Pail Complete Wlid And Bail Handle

Tiny Red - $72.00

Tiny Red Seal Peanut Butter Advertising Tin Pail Complete Wlid And Bail Handle

Jt Eaton™ Bait Block® Rodenticide With Peanut Butter Flavorizer, 9 Lb. Pail With

Jt Eaton™ - $66.82

Jt Eaton™ Bait Block® Rodenticide With Peanut Butter Flavorizer, 9 Lb. Pail With

Peanut Butter Tin Pail - Sultana - Great Atlantic -complete With Bail

Peanut Butter - $59.00

Peanut Butter Tin Pail - Sultana - Great Atlantic -complete With Bail

Vintage 6 14 High Shedd's Peanut Butter Tin Metal Circus Animals Pail

Vintage 6 - $63.99

Vintage 6 14 High Shedd's Peanut Butter Tin Metal Circus Animals Pail

Graphic Old Triangle Club Peanut Butter Tin Pail

Graphic Old - $56.00

Graphic Old Triangle Club Peanut Butter Tin Pail

Antique Wonder Peanut Butter 1 Lb Tin Pail Wheeler Barnes Minneapolis

Antique Wonder - $54.99

Antique Wonder Peanut Butter 1 Lb Tin Pail Wheeler Barnes Minneapolis

Vintage Pal Peanut Butter 5 Pound Tin Pail Container With Lid Nice

Vintage Pal - $52.00

Vintage Pal Peanut Butter 5 Pound Tin Pail Container With Lid Nice

Sunshine One 1 Pound Peanut Butter Tin, Pail Enterprise Coffee Company, Handle

Sunshine One - $55.99

Sunshine One 1 Pound Peanut Butter Tin, Pail Enterprise Coffee Company, Handle

Vintage Pal Peanut Butter 5 Pound Tin Pail Container With Lid Nice

Vintage Pal - $45.00

Vintage Pal Peanut Butter 5 Pound Tin Pail Container With Lid Nice

E And Z Peanut Butter Tin Pail Shamokin Pa

E And - $34.99

E And Z Peanut Butter Tin Pail Shamokin Pa

Vintage Old Rustic Thrifty Peanut Butter Tin Pail With Handle 3 38 Tall

Vintage Old - $49.99

Vintage Old Rustic Thrifty Peanut Butter Tin Pail With Handle 3 38 Tall

Vintage York Peanut Butter Tin Pail With Handle Has Red And White Finish

Vintage York - $34.99

Vintage York Peanut Butter Tin Pail With Handle Has Red And White Finish

Jt Eaton 709pn Rodenticide Bait Block, 9 Lb, Pail, Paraffin Block, Peanut Butter

Jt Eaton - $41.56

Jt Eaton 709pn Rodenticide Bait Block, 9 Lb, Pail, Paraffin Block, Peanut Butter

Vintage Tin Litho Circus Themed Peanut Butter Or Popcorn Pail Bucket

Vintage Tin - $32.50

Vintage Tin Litho Circus Themed Peanut Butter Or Popcorn Pail Bucket

Eaton Peanut Butter Rodent Bait Poison 9 Pail- Diphacinone

Eaton Peanut - $40.69

Eaton Peanut Butter Rodent Bait Poison 9 Pail- Diphacinone

 Old Reliable Peanut Butter Tin Can Pail Country Store Prop Free Ship Advertisin

Old - $39.99

Old Reliable Peanut Butter Tin Can Pail Country Store Prop Free Ship Advertisin

Jt Eaton Peanut Butter Bait Block® Rodenticide, 704-pn And 709 - 4 Lb Or 9 Lb Pail

Jt Eaton - $39.75

Jt Eaton Peanut Butter Bait Block® Rodenticide, 704-pn And 709 - 4 Lb Or 9 Lb Pail

Jt Eaton Peanut Butter Blocks - 709-pn - Rodenticide - Rat And Mouse Bait

Jt Eaton - $39.75

Jt Eaton Peanut Butter Blocks - 709-pn - Rodenticide - Rat And Mouse Bait

4 Lb Peanut Butter Flavor Bait Blocks Resealable Pail Kills Rats Only One

4 Lb - $38.07

4 Lb Peanut Butter Flavor Bait Blocks Resealable Pail Kills Rats Only One

Vintage Advertising Tin Swift's Peanut Butter Pail Bucket

Vintage Advertising - $24.99

Vintage Advertising Tin Swift's Peanut Butter Pail Bucket

Rayo Peanut Butter Pail Stiles - Pellens Coffee Co. Cincinnati, O Oh Ohio

Rayo Peanut - $29.99

Rayo Peanut Butter Pail Stiles - Pellens Coffee Co. Cincinnati, O Oh Ohio

Vtg Antique Peanut Butter Tin Can Pail Original Credo Cream Dove Binghamton, Ny

Vtg Antique - $29.99

Vtg Antique Peanut Butter Tin Can Pail Original Credo Cream Dove Binghamton, Ny

 Vintage....metal...sultana...peanut....butter....tin..pail

Vintage....metal...sultana...peanut....butter....tin..pail - $29.99

Vintage....metal...sultana...peanut....butter....tin..pail

Mice Rats Rodenticide Anticoagulant Bait Peanut Butter Flavor 9 Lb Pail 144pc

Mice Rats - $32.93

Mice Rats Rodenticide Anticoagulant Bait Peanut Butter Flavor 9 Lb Pail 144pc

5lb. Vintage The Peanut Kids Peanut Butter Tin Pail Vintage Suffolk Va

5lb. Vintage - $25.00

5lb. Vintage The Peanut Kids Peanut Butter Tin Pail Vintage Suffolk Va

Vintage 4 Lb Shedd's Peanut Butter Tin Can Pail With Handle

Vintage 4 - $21.37

Vintage 4 Lb Shedd's Peanut Butter Tin Can Pail With Handle

Vintage Shedd's Peanut Butter Tin Pail Graphics Animals Elves Advertising 1950's

Vintage Shedd's - $24.99

Vintage Shedd's Peanut Butter Tin Pail Graphics Animals Elves Advertising 1950's

Vintage Shedd's Peanut Butter Tin Can Bucket Pail

Vintage Shedd's - $21.00

Vintage Shedd's Peanut Butter Tin Can Bucket Pail

Rare Shedd's Peanut Butter Advertising Tin Pail Bucket Red Cover Collectible

Rare Shedd's - $29.99

Rare Shedd's Peanut Butter Advertising Tin Pail Bucket Red Cover Collectible

 Peru The Garbage Sos Album 46 Peanut Butter 'n Kellyout To Lunch Lance Pail

Peru - $24.95

Peru The Garbage Sos Album 46 Peanut Butter 'n Kellyout To Lunch Lance Pail

Vintage 1950's Shedds Peanut Butter Tin Pail 5 Lb Graphics Animals Elves

Vintage 1950's - $19.95

Vintage 1950's Shedds Peanut Butter Tin Pail 5 Lb Graphics Animals Elves

Vintage 1950's Shedds Peanut Butter Tin Pail W Lid 5 Lb Graphics Animals Elves

Vintage 1950's - $12.00

Vintage 1950's Shedds Peanut Butter Tin Pail W Lid 5 Lb Graphics Animals Elves

The Wizard Of Oz Swift's Oz Peanut Butter 2.2 Lb Yellow Sand Pail Tin

The Wizard - $19.99

The Wizard Of Oz Swift's Oz Peanut Butter 2.2 Lb Yellow Sand Pail Tin

Vintage 5 Lbs. Shedd's Peanut Butter Tin Pail With Lid

Vintage 5 - $17.25

Vintage 5 Lbs. Shedd's Peanut Butter Tin Pail With Lid

Vintage 1950's Shedds Peanut Butter Tin Pail W Lid 5 Lb Graphics Animals Elves

Vintage 1950's - $24.75

Vintage 1950's Shedds Peanut Butter Tin Pail W Lid 5 Lb Graphics Animals Elves

Vintage Shedd's Peanut Butter Advertising Tin Pail Bucket With Handle

Vintage Shedd's - $13.59

Vintage Shedd's Peanut Butter Advertising Tin Pail Bucket With Handle

Jt Eaton Peanut Butter Bait Block® Rodenticide, 704-pn And 709 - 4 Lb Or 9 Lb Pail

Jt Eaton - $23.29

Jt Eaton Peanut Butter Bait Block® Rodenticide, 704-pn And 709 - 4 Lb Or 9 Lb Pail

Vintage Advertising Tin,schwartz Peanut Butter, Halifax And Montreal, 2 Lb Pail

Vintage Advertising - $12.70

Vintage Advertising Tin,schwartz Peanut Butter, Halifax And Montreal, 2 Lb Pail

Vintage Shedd's Peanut Butter Advertising Tin Pail Bucket With Handle

Vintage Shedd's - $9.95

Vintage Shedd's Peanut Butter Advertising Tin Pail Bucket With Handle

Vtg Tin Lard Bucket Peanut Butter Pail 6 Orig Lid, Bail Handle. Has No Label.

Vtg Tin - $19.77

Vtg Tin Lard Bucket Peanut Butter Pail 6 Orig Lid, Bail Handle. Has No Label.

Vintage 5 Lbs. Shedd's Peanut Butter Tin Pail With Lid

Vintage 5 - $18.95

Vintage 5 Lbs. Shedd's Peanut Butter Tin Pail With Lid

Vintage Ann Page Krunchy Peanut Butter Plastic 5 Lb. Pail W Lid

Vintage Ann - $8.99

Vintage Ann Page Krunchy Peanut Butter Plastic 5 Lb. Pail W Lid

Kroger Peanut Butter 5 Pound Pail Bucket Jar With Lid And Handle Evansville In Ind

Kroger Peanut - $6.95

Kroger Peanut Butter 5 Pound Pail Bucket Jar With Lid And Handle Evansville In Ind

Vintage Shedd's Peanut Butter Advertising Tin Pail With Handle

Vintage Shedd's - $4.49

Vintage Shedd's Peanut Butter Advertising Tin Pail With Handle

Vintage Elf Peanut Butter Plastic Pail Bucket 4 Lbs. 64 Oz. Great Graphics

Vintage Elf - $8.99

Vintage Elf Peanut Butter Plastic Pail Bucket 4 Lbs. 64 Oz. Great Graphics

1988 Topps Garbage Pail Kids Series 12 493a Peanut Butter 'n Kelly Card 2f4

1988 Topps - $0.99

1988 Topps Garbage Pail Kids Series 12 493a Peanut Butter 'n Kelly Card 2f4

Garbage Pail Kids Peanut Butter 'n Kelly - 2 X 3 Fridge Locker Magnet

Garbage Pail - $4.95

Garbage Pail Kids Peanut Butter 'n Kelly - 2 X 3 Fridge Locker Magnet

1987 Garbage Pail Kids 12th Series 493a Peanut Butter 'n Kellynrmt

1987 Garbage - $1.25

1987 Garbage Pail Kids 12th Series 493a Peanut Butter 'n Kellynrmt

C1900 Merry Christmas Happy New Year Peanut Butter Candy Pail Litho Winter Fun

C1900 Merry - $440.00

C1900 Merry Christmas Happy New Year Peanut Butter Candy Pail Litho Winter Fun

Vintage Toyland Peanut Butter Pail Tin Advertising Collectible Graphic 127-v

Vintage Toyland - $165.00

Vintage Toyland Peanut Butter Pail Tin Advertising Collectible Graphic 127-v

Rival Peanut Butter Pail Vintage Collectible Advertising Tin 580-z

Rival Peanut - $149.00

Rival Peanut Butter Pail Vintage Collectible Advertising Tin 580-z

Monarch Peanut Butter Pail Vintage Collectible Advertising Tin 582-j

Monarch Peanut - $119.00

Monarch Peanut Butter Pail Vintage Collectible Advertising Tin 582-j

Tin Peanut Butter Pail - Bail Handle And Lid St. Laurent Bros.bay City, Michigan

Tin Peanut - $95.00

Tin Peanut Butter Pail - Bail Handle And Lid St. Laurent Bros.bay City, Michigan

Primitive Antique 25 Peanut Butter Pail United Indurated Fibre 1886 Red Paint

Primitive Antique - $79.99

Primitive Antique 25 Peanut Butter Pail United Indurated Fibre 1886 Red Paint

Tin Peanut Butter Pail W Bail Handle St. Laurent's Bros. Bay City, Michigan

Tin Peanut - $65.00

Tin Peanut Butter Pail W Bail Handle St. Laurent's Bros. Bay City, Michigan

St. Laurent Brothers Bay City Michigan10 Peanut Butter Pailbucket Tin Antique

St. Laurent - $55.00

St. Laurent Brothers Bay City Michigan10 Peanut Butter Pailbucket Tin Antique

Jt Eaton 709pn Rodenticide Bait Block, 9 Lb, Pail, Paraffin Block, Peanut Butter

Jt Eaton - $36.68

Jt Eaton 709pn Rodenticide Bait Block, 9 Lb, Pail, Paraffin Block, Peanut Butter

Vintage 1950's Shedds Peanut Butter Tin Pail  5 Lb Bucket W Handle, Animals

Vintage 1950's - $27.99

Vintage 1950's Shedds Peanut Butter Tin Pail 5 Lb Bucket W Handle, Animals

 Vintage Sultana Tin Peanut Butter Pail Vintage Advertising No Lid

Vintage - $24.99

Vintage Sultana Tin Peanut Butter Pail Vintage Advertising No Lid

Vintage Shedd's Peanut Butter Tin Can 5 Lb Bucket Pail With Handle

Vintage Shedd's - $15.00

Vintage Shedd's Peanut Butter Tin Can 5 Lb Bucket Pail With Handle